ABAA members provide a few pointers for beginning collectors who might be considering attending an antiquarian book fair for the first time.

Members Lorne Bair, Michael Hackenberg, John Schulman, and John Windle provide some advice gleaned from decades of book fair attendance.


Ask Questions/Develop Relationships with the Dealers

Examining Antique Maps

Veteran bookseller John Windle notes that "a good, close, trusting connection to a dealer will yield the best possible results," so book fairs present a valuable opportunity to get to know many dealers, and let them get to know you and your interests as a collector.

Lorne Bair agrees, adding that his "number one piece of advice to beginning collectors attending their first book fair is to ask questions! Antiquarian booksellers as a rule get very few opportunities to talk about their books with people who are genuinely interested. Book fairs are the one environment where they can open up, share their experience and expertise, and communicate with members of the public who share an enthusiasm for what they do."

John Schulman of Caliban Book Shop notes that "many exhibitors will bring along stacks of fair lists and their latest catalogs. Even if they don't buy anything, visitors should take copies of these and not be afraid to do so. They make great reading and even other dealers can learn a lot from their colleagues."

Examining the catalog

However, don't mistake the museum-quality artefacts with a museum's explicit invitation to stand around and admire all day. The object of book fairs is to sell books -- how else will the dealers be able to buy more books? Many dealers have traveled a long way to offer their particular treasures at the fair. Schulman cautions against standing "around in someone's booth talking to friends but not looking at the merchandise. Booths are small, time is limited, and other people who might potentially like to look at what's in a booth but can't, and whose purchases might mean the difference of a good show and a bad show to an exhibitor, should have a chance to get in and look around."

Bair concludes by underlining the value of a good relationshop between collectors and dealers: "a good bookseller is more than a merchant: she is a source of advice, encouragement, and accumulated wisdom. Great collections have always involved a collaboration between great collectors and great dealers, so don’t try to go it alone." 



Know Your Interest Areas

Rather than browse the aisles seeing what catches your eye, it's often best to go in with a plan: What areas are you interested in? Which items are you hunting? 

Michael Hackenberg of Hackenberg Booksellers advises collectors “definitely have the subject areas of interest in mind, and some of the books in those areas of specific interest." But, even if you're not sure where you ultimately want your collection to go, a few fixed reference points can be great conversation starters when meeting dealers, who will be only to happy to share their knowledge and advise on refining your focus. 

John Windle feels either approach is valid: "the 'I'll know it when I see it' is a great way to buy, but having a focus and at least the basis of a list of wants is a great start."

You never know what you might find


Then, Buy the Best Copies You Can Afford

Lorne Bair advises new collectors "avoid the temptation to buy defective and/or restored books. The best collections are not always the largest." Reading a wide range of dealer catalogs is useful, but not essential.

John Windle notes that it's good to know the going rate for items of interest, and also to gain some understanding of "what each dealer means by fine" and other notes on condition. 

ABC for Book Collectors


ABC for Book Collectors, by John Carter, is a very useful introduction to the technical terms and phrases used in the rare-book trade.  


But, Don't Buy for Investment

"Once you’ve found a dealer with whom you enjoy doing business, who sells the kind of books you’re looking for, and who shows a genuine grasp of your collecting interests — develop a relationship!" notes Lorne Bair.  But, don't "buy for investment. Books are not securities. Buy what you love and let your own taste be your guide. Many of the most interesting collections are comprised of materials that nobody considered valuable until some collector thought to assemble them." 

A good collection is more than the merits of each individual piece, it lies in what the collection illustrates, what it reveals in the relation between the items. A good collection is quite literally more than the sum of its parts.


Museum-quality artefacts


On a more practical level:

Don't Be Afraid to Touch the Books (Gently)

Part of the thrill of a book fair is to see and touch volumes you have only heard of, or never knew existed!  Windle comments that "handling rare books is an essential skill and if in doubt ask the dealer to help until you feel confident with a $250,000 book in your hands and $100 in your pocket." Hackenberg advises excited new collectors to "use caution by not splaying volumes open or slapping through pages. Dealers will gladly assist novices on book handling etiquette.” Schulman cautions that "there's a chance that if a book is damaged from your mishandling it, the dealer will obligate you to compensate him/her for the damage." So keep food and drinks away from the books, make sure your hands are clean, and if in doubt, ask.

Schulman suggests that when attending the big, ABAA-sponsored fairs like California, New York, and Boston, collectors "should make a point of going into the booths of the dealers from abroad -- they all speak English and they all have items on display you'll never see anywhere else." 

He concludes that "visitors should not be cowed and intimidated by either the high price of some of items or the general air of splendor evident in many booths. The merchants are usually willing and eager to discuss what they've brought, and even if you can't afford what they're offering, you'll get a chance to see some museum quality items up close and learn more about these items from real enthusiasts."  


New York Antiquarian Book Fair

Most forms of payment are accepted

While cash might be impractical for higher-end rarities, John Windle notes that "dealers love cash not for nefarious reasons but because it gives them some spending money in the pocket for purchases, entertainment, etc. when they've been stuck in a hall for four days and have run out of cash!" Book dealers are collectors themselves, and often unexpectedly find essential items to acquire for their own collectors, and like most book lovers, are quite content to forego other pleasures to prevent an exciting book getting away.

John Schulman offers several points on etiquette:

  • Never bargain with an exhibitor over an item's price. The exhibitor wants to build a relationship with future clients and collectors, but that's impossible if it begins with negotiations. If you have a collecting interest and see an item you want and you believe the dealer might offer other such items to you in the future, pay what's on the price tag and you'll be rewarded by getting offered items first in the future. The dealer might offer a lower price to you on their own, which is lovely, but don't initiate that yourself.
  • Don't look up something on your smart phone while standing in a dealer's booth to see if it is available for less online. That's just rude. And don't begin any sentence addressed to an exhibitor with "But on eBay..."  

Most dealers bring items at all price-levels, so there should be interesting and desireable books and ephemera to suit every collectors' budget.

The action at the booth


Attend Seminars

Many of a larger book fairs -- like the New York Antiquarian Book Fair -- organize some seminars or lectures on topics or authors of interest. These are great opportunities to learn more about an area of interest, and also a good chance to meet like-minded collectors and dealers.

“Discovery Days” are a chance to bring in an item or two along for appraisal, and in the process learn more about how professionals evaluate antiquarian books. Not all fairs offer this feature, so check the fair website before you go.


Antiquarian book fairs are welcoming places, full of collectors and dealers eager to talk about books and examine rarities and beautiful manuscripts. Dealers are happy to discuss and display their wares, and forge new friendships from shared interests in books and collecting. 

Learn more about upcoming book fairs on our events page...


Don't miss an article from The New Antiquarian blog.

Subscribe to the ABAA email newsletter!

* indicates required
Email Format